Other cultures
We had a 'neat' choir practice last night, running through about a dozen Christmas carols and songs and a few 'quasi-Christmas' items if you can include Mozart's 'Ave Verum' and a couple of 'gospel' items in that list. They really have the 'swing' of Christmas these days, we are singing all the 'regular' repertoire stuff as well as any English church choir. We will soon be up to speed for our Christmas carol concert sessions at the Radisson Hotel at Narita.
But Edera posed an interesting question over breakfast this morning - as a non-Christian myself how do I feel about helping a Japanese choir to learn this stuff? Christmas Day is not even a public holiday here although it features in the stores from early November and small kids certainly know all about Santa.
I'm not sure that I ever particularly thought of Christmas as Christian - after all they only took over the earlier pagan festival of Yule. No one really knows when Jesus was born. In northern latitudes we need something to cheer ourselves up in midwinter and mark the turn of the year. And carols are a 'cultural' aspect of the season, something that you remember from myths you were taught in your own childhood rather than having any doctrinal significance. Actually it really surprises me how, now that we have sung carols for three years, the same sort of spirit creeps into singers' hearts here. People LOVE to sing traditional carols.
And at the same time it's a fair question. Whatever good reasons there may be for singing carols it's not Japanese for sure. Harmony and polyphony are not classic Japanese musical forms. And "Hark the Herald ...!" would not have gone down well with Tokugawa Ieyasu eh? For better or worse I'd better remember that I'm playing my own tiny and unwitting part in spreading a foreign culture












