Impulsive choices
For bed time reading at the moment I've just got my nose into 'The Pilgrimage of Grace' by Geoffrey Moorhouse. If you don't know much English history the 'Pilgrimage of Grace' was a major rebellion against Henry VIII that swept across northern England in 1536, beginning in Louth in Lincolnshire but eventually affecting all the counties from Yorkshire and Cheshire north to the Scottish border.
The causes for this rebellion were complex - aren't they always! - but a big part of it was resentment about the ways in which old systems of Christian belief and practice were being reformed by the State. Then as now, us northerners couldn't abide educated southern politicians with axes to grind (in those days literally!) sitting down in London and telling us what to do and think.
But the thing that has really caught my attention in this book is the ease with which ordinary people could slip over the boundary between 'loyalty' and 'rebellion' - a kind of graphic version of taking 'life changing decisions'. There they were minding their own business digging the garden and then someone rode up with a piece of dramatic news - say rumour had it that Thomas Cromwell was going to 'privatise' their town church and sell the lead on the roof. Suddenly in one moment through one spontaneous choice they have become a rebel who the King's commanders will later put to death, no way back to their former lives. The proverb runs 'marry in haste, repent at leisure' but the principle applies to all kinds of motivation for impulsive action. There is no gradual transition through grey involved with choices like this, no time to wonder. It is white one moment and black the next. Most people probably didn't even get to make their own decision, they found themselves in the middle of a mob with people insisting that they took an 'oath of allegiance' to the new cause - or else. In Tudor times people took such oaths very seriously.
This has always been a puzzle to me. There are many situations in life where bad choices DO have a slow cumulative effect, say a poor diet or a negative attitude to something. And then on other occasions just one blink of the eye is enough to bring the whole house crashing down, choose tofu for lunch instead of beans and suddenly the rest of your life is fundamentally changed. And the thing is that a sixth sense often warns us at the time that this is 'one of those choices'


