Need for novelty
I took a couple of hours out from nursing Pero last night to go to the men's choir practice. It is the first time I have made a rehearsal since August: we only meet once a month as a rule and there was no meeting in September for reasons I forget now. Anyway, everyone was pleased to see me back.
I say 'everyone' but we were two tenors down so 'sensei' have to double up as one of the group. We are thin on the ground these days and we certainly need lots of practice! We are also working over a lot of pieces that we learned long ago and that feels like a bit of a problem to me, if we don't get any new challenges then we go on making the same old mistakes again and again. It surprises me how choirs he can just rehearse and rehearse the same old music on the unspoken assumption that you go on getting better and better. It 'aint so. Apart from the fact that you can sing something a million times and still be out of tune if you don't get a challenge in what you do then you aren't going to learn anything. Your underlying ability doesn't grow.
I suppose it is the same in everything you do. Japan is a culture that still puts a lot of store by the value of a lifetime's skill in one craft. On TV here I see lots of programmes about making lacquer ware bowls or wooden screens or thatching old houses, people love the idea that there is magical skill deeply embedded in someone's hands. And of course there is a very profound relationship between these people and their craft, objects just 'flow out of their fingers' and they are special. What Lefebvre would refer to as 'oeuvres', the difference between mass production and hand crafted objects.
The difference between this and amateur singing is that typically the people that develop these skills spend years perfecting in detail the basics of their craft. Professional musicians do the same. But in singing you need both technique and experience, the experience comes from trying many 'tastes', setting yourself problems to resolve, being a bit ambitious. Do you want to sing 'Polly put the kettle on' perfectly or a piece of Palestina badly? Or both?



