No more 'Dog Bites Man' for me
I was half-listening to the news on our new TV yesterday as I took some stuff through into the kitchen and overheard a piece about the 'New Year' celebrations here in Japan. This year, the reporter was telling everyone, it seems that many people will be visiting temples over the holiday period.
Huh? That is news?? People have been visiting temples here at New Year since the days of Prince Shotoku back in the seventh century. The date of New Year changed in 1873, I'll give you that, but temple visiting at New Year, that hasn't.
I often puzzle over that famous advice to young reporters from the nineteenth century journalist Charles Anderson Dana. "If a dog bites a man, that isn't news, but if a man bites a dog, then that is news." If only it was true eh? Was it ever true I wonder? It should be that way, but these days probably 99.5% of all news is in the "dog bites man" category. Politicians promise bright futures, people rush to closing down sales, our folks hate all of their folks, the Tokyo rush hour is crowded, taxes soar, currencies slump, scientists predict that tomorrow the sun will rise in the East. I feel a line from Ecclesiastes coming on here.
All this betrays a tendency to think only in the worst kind of cliche, to allow our brain cells to be permeated and bonded by quick-setting super-strength stereotypes. The old cycle of repeating the same stale conventions because readers, listeners, viewers all need comfortable routines, as if we couldn't cope with other versions of truth and visions of reality. And then there's the pressure on journalists to go on churning the wretched stuff out. "Heck! This seventy seconds or hundred words has to be with the news desk by 3:17 pm, do you think we have time left for originality?"
This kind of mindless journalism is a menace of the dimensions of bubonic plague. It starts seemingly innocently with the local weekly 'rag' using verbatim a couple of paragraphs from the Women's Institute on a talk about 'fair trade' in Uruguay (Chairman's hairdressing salon runs regular adverts!) and ends with political correspondents recycling so-called press releases on dodgy foreign wars handed out by politicians and generals at 'off the record briefings'. "It begins with your family but soon it gets around to your soul" to quote Leonard Cohen.
You think I'm being hard on them? When did you last take a good look at the contents of a national newspaper. You would be better off believing in fairies than most of that stuff.
So that will be one of my many, many New Year's Resolutions for 2009. Look every 'news story' straight in the eye. How about yours?
And a Happy New Year to all regular readers!













